I thought of a relatively simple solution to incentivize people to stay blue, without it being too punishing to be red. Every 100 alignment above 0 gives +10% to quest rewards. Every 100 alignment below 0 gives -10% to quest rewards. Bam, a saint can now get 8k gold and 4 rare ores from iklith quest, while reds gain slightly below the base reward, up to no reward whatsoever at -1000. No effect on pvp or higher end spawns, but a nice boost to meditation points for newbs and solo players. Also, higher alignment should give more boosts to living in npc cities, and lower alignment should give boosts to living in chaos cities. Could be faster recalls, cheaper crafting gold costs, better vendor sale prices, anything small but sizable. All of these would help keep people at extremes of alignments and discourage farming to 1 alignment, killing, farming it back up.